| Updated in 3/9/2023 2:00:09 AM |
Viewed: 53 times |
(Journal Article) |
Revista da Associacao Medica Brasileira (1992) 66 (12): 1696-1701 (2020)
Bilateral simultaneous percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus staged approach: a critical analysis of complications and renal function.
Fabio C M Torricelli
,
Regina S Carvalho
,
Giovanni S Marchini
,
Alexandre Danilovic
,
Fabio C Vicentini
,
Carlos A Batagello
,
Miguel Srougi
,
William C Nahas
,
Eduardo Mazzucchi
ABSTRACT
Patients with bilateral kidney stones and burdened by large stones are challenging cases for endourologists. Simultaneous bilateral percutaneous nephrolithotomy (sbPCNL) is an option; however, it may be accompanied by important morbidity. An alternative is a staged PCNL, operating one side each time. Herein, we compare the impact of sbPCNL and staged PCNL on complication rates and renal function.Patients who underwent sbPCNL or staged bilateral PCNL with a frame time of 6 months were searched in our prospectively collected kidney stone database. Groups were compared for age, gender, body mass index (BMI), comorbidities (classification by the American Society of Anesthesiology - ASA), stone size, Guy's score, stone-free status, renal function, blood loss, blood transfusion rate, complication rate, and length of hospital stay.Twenty-six patients and 52 kidney units were enrolled. The mean operative time was 134.7 min. Only 11.3% of cases had complications, all of them minor (Clavien ≤ 2). Overall, the stone-free rate was 61.50%. Comparing the groups, there was a significantly longer operative time in the sbPCNL group (172.5 vs. 126.3 min; p=0.016), as well as a higher transfusion rate (12.5% vs. 5.6%; p=0.036). There was no statistically significant difference in creatinine levels between the groups. Regarding the stone-free rate, there was a significantly higher proportion of patients in the staged PCNL group (64.9% vs. 43.8%; p=0.012).sbPCNL is a safe procedure; however, when compared to staged procedures it has a higher transfusion and lower stone-free rate.